Let's be honest: Thanksgiving is the Super Bowl of family dinners, and not every dish deserves a spot on your plate. Some foods are universally loved, some spark heated debates, and others... well, they're only there because Aunt Carol insists on making them every year.
As a lifelong North Carolinian who's attended more Thanksgiving dinners than I can count (and as your local Elkin insurance agent who's heard plenty of holiday hosting stories), I'm settling this debate once and for all. Here's my definitive ranking of the 5 best and 5 worst Thanksgiving foods—plus some practical tips to make sure your holiday gathering is safe, delicious, and stress-free.
The Top 5: Thanksgiving's MVPs (Most Valuable Plates)
These are the dishes that make Thanksgiving worth the inevitable food coma. If these aren't on your table, are you even celebrating Thanksgiving?
🍗 Perfectly Roasted Turkey
The star of the show. When done right, turkey is juicy, flavorful, and the reason we're all here. Whether you're team brine, team butter-under-the-skin, or team deep-fried-in-the-driveway (looking at you, North Carolina), a well-prepared turkey is non-negotiable.
Safety Tip: Deep frying a turkey? Make sure your homeowners insurance is up to date. Those things are basically controlled explosions. Use them outdoors, away from structures, and never on a deck or in a garage.
🥔 Mashed Potatoes & Gravy
Creamy, buttery, covered in rich gravy—mashed potatoes are the comfort food we all need. They're the Switzerland of Thanksgiving dishes: universally loved, never controversial, and they go with everything. Bonus points if you leave some lumps for texture.
🥧 Homemade Stuffing (or Dressing, if you're Southern)
Whether you stuff it in the bird or bake it separately (we're not here to fight that battle), good stuffing is a masterpiece of herbs, butter, and perfectly toasted bread. It's the dish that disappears first and sparks the most recipe requests.
🍠 Sweet Potato Casserole (with the marshmallow topping)
Since North Carolina is the #1 sweet potato producer in the nation, this dish is basically our state obligation. The debate over whether it's a side dish or a dessert only makes it better. Those caramelized marshmallows on top? *Chef's kiss.*
🥧 Pumpkin Pie (with real whipped cream)
The official dessert of Thanksgiving. That perfect balance of spices, the smooth custard filling, the flaky crust—it's autumn in food form. And if you're using Cool Whip instead of real whipped cream, we need to have a conversation.
"Turkey, mashed potatoes, stuffing, sweet potato casserole, and pumpkin pie: The Thanksgiving starting lineup that never disappoints. 🦃"
Click to Tweet This
The Bottom 5: Thanksgiving's Bench Warmers
Look, somebody has to say it. Not every traditional Thanksgiving dish deserves its place at the table. Here are the five foods that need to retire (or at least get a serious recipe makeover):
🥗 Canned Cranberry Sauce (the jiggly kind)
This one's divisive. Some people love the nostalgic ridges from the can. Others think it's a crime against cranberries. I'm in the latter camp. Fresh cranberry sauce takes 15 minutes to make and tastes infinitely better. That gelatinous cylinder isn't food—it's a science experiment.
🥕 Overcooked Green Bean Casserole
When done right, green bean casserole is delicious. But let's be honest: it's rarely done right. Most of the time, it's a soggy mess of canned everything, crowned with those French fried onions that somehow manage to be both burnt and soggy. Fresh green beans exist, people.
🥖 Dry, Store-Bought Dinner Rolls
Why are we serving breadsticks at Thanksgiving when stuffing already exists? If you must have dinner rolls, at least make them from scratch or get the good ones from a bakery. Those rock-hard store-bought ones are just taking up valuable plate real estate.
🥗 That Mystery Jello Salad
You know the one. It's usually bright green or red, contains mysterious chunks of fruit (and possibly mini marshmallows or shredded carrots), and suspends everything in gelatin. Someone's grandmother swears by it, but nobody under 40 will touch it. Time to let this relic of 1950s cuisine rest in peace.
🌽 Canned Corn (straight from the can)
We're in North Carolina, folks. Fresh corn is available, and it's infinitely better than the metallic-tasting canned variety dumped in a bowl. If you're serving canned corn without even heating it up or adding butter... I'm worried about you. Show the corn some respect.
Build Your Perfect Thanksgiving Plate
Select your favorite dishes and we'll reveal your Thanksgiving personality type!
Check all the dishes you'd put on your Thanksgiving plate:
Hosting Thanksgiving this year? Make sure your homeowners insurance covers holiday guests and potential kitchen mishaps. Call (336) 835-1993 for a free policy review.
Hosting Thanksgiving? Let's Talk About Your Coverage
Thanksgiving is wonderful—until someone slips on your front steps or your kitchen catches fire. As your local independent agent, I represent 8+ top carriers and can ensure you're properly protected for holiday hosting.
- Liability coverage for guest injuries
- Protection for cooking-related damage
- Peace of mind for your holiday celebration
Safe Thanksgiving Hosting Tips (From Your Local Insurance Agent)
Alright, now that we've settled the food debate, let's talk about something importantâ€"making sure your Thanksgiving celebration is safe. As someone who's seen plenty of holiday insurance claims over 20+ years, here's my practical advice:
Kitchen Safety (The #1 Source of Thanksgiving Incidents)
- Never leave cooking food unattended – This is when most kitchen fires start. If you're deep-frying a turkey, stay with it the entire time.
- Keep a fire extinguisher accessible – And make sure you know how to use it before Thanksgiving Day.
- Use a thermometer – Undercooked turkey isn't just bad for your guests' taste buds—it can cause serious foodborne illness.
- Clear the cooking area – Keep pot handles turned inward and remove anything flammable from the stovetop area.
Guest Safety
- Clear walkways and entry areas – November in NC can mean wet leaves and slippery steps. Make sure paths are clear and well-lit.
- Secure rugs and remove tripping hazards – A slip-and-fall is the last thing you want during your celebration.
- Keep pets secure – Even the friendliest dog can get overwhelmed with a house full of guests.
- Designate parking areas – Avoid having cars block driveways or park on grass that could become muddy.
The Insurance Conversation (I Promise It's Not Boring)
Your standard homeowners insurance policy includes liability coverage, which protects you if a guest is injured at your home. However, many North Carolina families don't have adequate coverage limits. Here's what I recommend:
- Review your liability limits – Most policies default to $100,000-$300,000, but that might not be enough if someone is seriously injured.
- Consider an umbrella policy – For $200-400 per year, you can add $1-2 million in additional liability coverage. It's the best insurance bargain available.
- Document your belongings – Take photos of your home and valuables before the holidays. If something happens, you'll have proof for your claim.
- Know what's covered – Most policies cover cooking-related damage, but there are exclusions. A quick call to your agent can clarify your coverage.
North Carolina Thanksgiving Traditions
Since we're proud North Carolinians, let's talk about what makes Thanksgiving special in our state:
Sweet Potato Everything
North Carolina produces more sweet potatoes than any other state in the nation. Johnston County alone grows over 60% of the country's supply. So when you're eating sweet potato casserole, sweet potato pie, or candied yams, you're eating North Carolina agriculture at its finest.
The Turkey Trot Tradition
Many NC communities host Turkey Trot 5K races on Thanksgiving morning. Elkin's annual Turkey Trot starts at 8am at Elkin Municipal Park—a great way to earn your dinner before you eat it!
Blue Ridge Parkway Views
While some families watch football, others take a scenic drive on the Blue Ridge Parkway to see the last of the fall foliage. Just remember: the Parkway can be foggy and icy in November, so drive carefully and make sure your auto insurance is current.
Community Thanksgiving Dinners
Throughout Surry County and surrounding areas, churches and community organizations host free Thanksgiving dinners for those who might otherwise be alone. It's a beautiful reminder of what the holiday is really about.
North Carolina Thanksgiving Quick Facts
- NC Sweet Potato Production: North Carolina grows over 2 billion pounds of sweet potatoes annually—about 60% of the U.S. supply.
- Turkey Production: NC ranks in the top 10 states for turkey production, raising over 30 million turkeys each year.
- Average Thanksgiving Spending: NC families spend an average of $60-80 on their Thanksgiving meal.
- Most Popular Side: In NC, mashed potatoes and gravy narrowly beat out sweet potato casserole as the most popular side dish.
"Last Thanksgiving, my turkey fryer tipped over and caught my deck on fire. Thank goodness Bill had made sure my homeowners policy covered that kind of incident. His advice to keep a fire extinguisher nearby probably saved my house. Now I call him before every major holiday!"
Common Questions About Thanksgiving Foods & Hosting
What's the best way to thaw a frozen turkey safely?
The safest method is thawing in the refrigerator, which takes about 24 hours for every 4-5 pounds of turkey. A 15-pound turkey needs 3-4 days to thaw completely. Never thaw on the counter at room temperature—that's a recipe for food poisoning. If you're in a time crunch, you can use the cold water method (submerged in cold water, changing the water every 30 minutes), but the fridge method is safest and requires less attention.
Are there any Thanksgiving foods unique to North Carolina?
Sweet potato pie is a quintessential North Carolina Thanksgiving dessert. Since we're the leading producer of sweet potatoes in the U.S., it's a dish we excel at. Some NC families also include regional favorites like collard greens, cornbread dressing (instead of traditional stuffing), and NC-style pulled pork as an alternative to turkey. The Moravian community in Winston-Salem area often includes Moravian sugar cake as a Thanksgiving dessert.
Does homeowners insurance cover Thanksgiving-related incidents?
Yes, generally. Most homeowners policies include liability coverage for guest injuries and coverage for fire or cooking-related damage. However, there are limits and exclusions. For example, if a guest is injured due to your negligence (like not salting icy steps), your liability coverage would typically respond. Kitchen fires from cooking are usually covered, but intentional acts or gross negligence might not be. I always recommend reviewing your policy before hosting major events. A quick call to your agent can clarify exactly what's covered.
How long can Thanksgiving leftovers safely stay in the fridge?
Most Thanksgiving leftovers are safe in the refrigerator for 3-4 days when stored properly in airtight containers. Turkey and stuffing should be refrigerated within 2 hours of cooking. If you're not going to eat leftovers within 4 days, freeze them—they'll keep for 2-3 months. When reheating, make sure everything reaches 165°F internally. And here's a pro tip: if you're traveling with leftovers, make sure your auto insurance is current just in case something happens on the drive home!
What should I do if I have a kitchen fire on Thanksgiving?
First, safety: Get everyone out of the house and call 911. Never try to fight a large fire yourself. For small grease fires, you can use a fire extinguisher (never water!), or smother it with a lid or baking soda. Once the fire is out and everyone is safe, document the damage with photos and contact your insurance agent immediately. Your homeowners policy should cover the damage, and your agent can help you file a claim and arrange for temporary housing if needed. This is why I always stress having a fire extinguisher in your kitchen and knowing how to use it before the holiday.
Is turkey really the healthiest Thanksgiving main dish?
Actually, yes! Turkey is a lean protein that's high in tryptophan (which helps you sleep), B vitamins, and selenium. White meat is particularly low in fat. The health problems at Thanksgiving usually come from the sides (loaded with butter, cream, and sugar) and the massive portion sizes. A 3-4 ounce serving of turkey without the skin is actually a very healthy choice. Of course, after you've had three helpings of everything else, that nutritional benefit gets a bit lost in the shuffle!
The Bottom Line: Build Your Perfect Plate
Whether you agree with my rankings or think I'm completely wrong about cranberry sauce (it's okay—we can still be friends), the beauty of Thanksgiving is that you get to build your own perfect plate. Load it up with the classics, skip the dishes you don't like, and maybe—just maybe—try that controversial Jello salad your grandmother keeps making.
What matters most isn't whether you prefer fresh cranberry sauce or the canned variety. It's gathering with the people you care about, being grateful for what you have, and creating memories that last long after the leftovers are gone.
From everyone at Bill Layne Insurance, we wish you and your family a safe, delicious, and drama-free Thanksgiving. May your turkey be moist, your sides be plentiful, and your guests arrive without incident.
And hey—if you're hosting this year and want to make sure your insurance coverage is ready, give me a call. I promise to be quicker than thawing a turkey.
Get Your Free Pre-Holiday Insurance Review
Before you start cooking, let me make sure your home and auto insurance are ready for the holiday season. No cost, no pressure—just honest advice from a neighbor.
Get More Local Tips & Insurance Advice
Join 500+ North Carolina families who receive my monthly newsletter with community news, holiday tips, and money-saving insurance strategies.
Local news & tips only. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
More Helpful Resources
Winter Weather Insurance Prep for NC Homeowners Contact Us Service Center Videos Community Blog Resources Claims Center Home Insurance Auto Insurance Areas We Serve
Essential coverage tips to protect your home from ice, snow, and winter storms.
Read moreWhat's Happening in Surry County This November
Your complete guide to local events, Thanksgiving celebrations, and community gatherings.
Read moreComplete Guide to NC Homeowners Insurance
Everything North Carolina homeowners need to know about coverage and savings.
Read moreAbout Bill Layne
Bill Layne has been serving North Carolina families as an independent insurance agent since 2004. A lifelong resident of Elkin, Bill knows our community inside and out—from the best places to buy fresh sweet potatoes to which roads get icy first in winter. He represents top carriers including Nationwide, Progressive, Travelers, and more, allowing him to find the best coverage at the best price for his neighbors. When he's not helping clients save on insurance, you'll find Bill at local events, enjoying Thanksgiving dinner with his family, and probably having strong opinions about cranberry sauce. (It should be homemade, people.)